The Mystery of the 69th Pennsylvania's Irish Flags

On the afternoon of July 3, 1863 Pickett's Virginians charged the Bloody Angle at the Gettysburg battlefield. This was the main confederate attack to crack  the Union line. Defending the left side of the Bloody Angle was the 69th Pennsylvania, a volunteer Irish regiment from Philadelphia, dubbed the "Gallant 69th" by General  Joseph Hooker for the regiment's work on the Virginia peninsula in 1862.

Captain Cowan was ordered to bring his New York artillery battery into the Bloody Angle. As Cowan and his men were gearing up, Cowan heard an Irish private named Billy Smith, nicknamed "the Wild Irishman"  exclaim as Smith lifted himself up in his stirrups, waving his whip with wild excitement, shouting "Hurrah for the 'ould flag." Smith had spotted the green Irish  flag  of the 69th Pennsylvania in the middle of the Blood Angle. 

Today on the 69th's monument (below-right),  the highest motif is a large Maid of Ireland (left). Was this the 'ould flag and what did the flag look like? 

Turning to Mc'Dermott's book he described the flag "painted with the Coat of Arms of Pennsylvania on the reverse side with three Irish symbols: the wolf, round tower and sunburst, on the obverse side" That settled that or did it? I could not ignore the large Maid of Ireland flag as the highest symbol on the monument. More research was on my plate.

Then another complication the 69th was a three year regiment and would surrender its flags before reorganizing as the 69th Pennsylvania Veteran Volunteers. So there would be two sets of flags. Major Davis surrendered the first set of flags to Philadelphia about April 18-20,1864 .  There would be a second set of flags issued for the Veteran Volunteer regiment. Later a salient item appeared: Major, later Colonel Davis was an ardent Fenian, holding a Lt. Colonel's commission in the Fenian Brotherhood. Then it clicked----the sunburst on the flag! The sunburst was the universal symbol of Fenianism. Perhaps Davis used his influence to have the Sunburst placed on the second flag. McDermott was Davis' protégé and  McDermott was and a Fenian,too. If my theory were true, I would have to track down some description of the first flag.

In the Irish-American  of March 1, 1862, "Arangements are being made by the ladies of this city (Philly) to present the 69th Pennsylvania Regiment,Colonel Owen commanding, with a stand of Irish colors. The regiment has now been nearly in service and in all that time has carried their own National flag."

Irish-American newspaper April 22, 1862, "Their friends in this city (Philly) , being some of them our leading Irish-Americans , are about presenting them with a beautiful green flag trimmed in gold the old Irish Harp  representing upon one side 'Presented to the 69th Pennsylvania Regiment by their friends :"upon the reverse is the Coat of  Arms of the State."

In early May near Fortress Monroe, Virginia the flag was taken to the regiment and accepted by Colonel Owen with great ceremony.

Sadly to say, the regiment's Irish flags were stolen from Liberty Hall before 1870. However the first Irish flag waves over the battlefield at Gettysburg---no longer in silk----but in granite---on the 69th Pennsylvania's monument.

Top: Painting by Don Troiani (HistoricalArtPrints.com)

Other Articles from TWG on the Irish in the US Civil War

John Logan, “The Black Eagle of Illinois”: From Bigot to Black Rights Activist

Civil War General John “Black Jack” Logan: “The Radiant Incarnation of War.”

The Irish in the American Civil War Monument

Origin of the Word 'Deadline'

Memorial Day: Recalling Those Who Gave Their Last Full Measure

Dispatches From Antietam: Irish Join Throng Marking The Battle's 14...

A Union Officer, A Dublin Backmark Trans-Atlantic sleuthing finally...

Building a trail to recall the Irish role in America’s bloodiest war

Bust of Thomas Francis Meagher Destined for Brooklyn

With Dublin Talk, Irish Gov'ment Highlights America's Civil War

'If It Had Only Been For Ireland': John C. Mitchel Dies in Carolina

Soldier Jennie Hodgers: Irish Woman Fought in America's Civil War

Irish Fight for Union Resounds

Emma Kline: Hoop-Skirt Smuggler During the Siege of Vicksburg

SRO Event Launches Irish Commemoration of America’s Civil War

Those Wonderful, Intelligent Irish Genes - Thank You, Ireland

Gods and Generals: 'Stonewalling' the Civil War

The Stories Behind the Songs: 'Kelly's Irish Brigade'

Irish in America's Civil War with Damian Shiels, Robbie Doyle, Gerr...

The History Show , RTE Radio 1 American Civil War and the Contribut...

A Dog’s Tale: Pat and Mike Go To War

'The Irish Volunteer' Finds His Bard: David Kincaid's new CD resurr...

Color Sergeant Michael Brady: The Luckiest Irishman in America's Ci...

Jews Who Fought in Famed Irish Brigade's 28th Massachusetts

The Irish at Sabine Pass -- September 6-8, 1863

Confederate Hero, Dick Dowling: Miracle at Sabine Pass

Grab Keneally’s Biography of an ‘American Scoundrel’

Brevet Brigadier General Peter John Sullivan

The History of the Irish Brigade

The Stories Behind the Songs: 'The Irish Sixty-Ninth'

Memorials, Tombstones and Cenotaphs

In `92, Billy Yank and Johnnie Reb March in Dublin

Christmas in the Union's Irish Brigades Part 1 of 2: Early War In t...

Remembering the Irish Who Fell at Fredericksburg

Cleburne: Let Blacks Fight for the Confederacy

St. Patrick's Day's Powerful Tug

Special Report: The Irish Battle at Antietam: 140th anniversary

Mary Brady: Angel of the Battlefield

Tom Sweeny: He Wasn't Called "Fighting Tom" For Nothing

Sheridan Rides to Lincoln's Rescue in 1864 Election Parts 1 & 2

Corcoran: From Bane to Toast of the Nation: Parts 1 through 5

Cleburne: A Confederate 'Meteor'

Irish Brigade Clears Way for Governor Mario Cuomo, March 1991

LIVE Community Chat with Mike Harrington - Sunday, Sep. 8 (Sabine Pass)

An Irishwoman at War (Irish Heritage Week 2020)

'The Fighting 69th' Parts 1 &  2 

‘Meagher of the Sword’ – The Civil War Legend and His Kildare Boyhood

The American Civil War at Christmastime: A Community Chat with Kevi...

Private Luke Quinn, USMC, Was He The First Casualty of The American...

U.S. Grant's Ancestral Homestead in Tyrone

The Confederate Monument Issue: Is it Pride or Prejudice?

Cleburne's Incendiary Proposal: Let Blacks Fight for the Confederacy

Confederate Hero, Dick Dowling: Miracle at Sabine Pass

Cleburne: The Defense of Ringgold Gap

Call for Tuam Town Hall to remove memorial to Irish Confederate major

Disquieting Kiss: Embracing the Blue, Gray and Green

Recalling the 155th New York Volunteer Infantry 'Corcoran's Irish L...

'Free and Green': Song -- and Fate -- Bring Limelight to Civil War ...

Scrappy Phil Sheridan - The U.S. Army's Little Big Man

Sheridan Rides to Lincoln's Rescue in 1864 Election

Galvanized Yankees

General Phil Kearny: 'The One-Armed Devil'

Irish Dominate Medal of Honor List

James J. Shields: Tyrone Native Served America Well—and Often

The Stories Behind the Songs: 'Camp Song of the Chicago Irish Brigade'

'South Wind': Awakening the Silent Voices of America's Civil War

"Their Stories, Our Heritage, Not Forgotten" Irish Heritage Week, 2...

The Call to Arms: The Irish at 1st Bull Run, Parts 1 through 5

The Civil War and the Irish in New Orleans

Father Peter Cooney, CSC: Chaplain of 35th Indiana (1st Irish)

Dying Together: From Bull Run to Baghdad

An Irishman In The 8th Ohio Volunteers

The Confederate Monument Issue: Is It Pride or Prejudice?

The Irish Sword': A Community Chat All About Dick Dowling, with Mik...

The Deadliest Day: The Irish Brigade at Bloody Lane, September 17, ...

'The Fighting 69th' Makes History, Yet Again

Mayo's Robert Horatio George Minty: Past Imperfect Hero

Defender of the Faith: Commander Aids Pope, U.S. Army

'Born a Soldier': Myles Walter Keogh - Part 1 through 3: From Carlo...

Dispatches From Antietam: Irish Join Throng Marking The Battle's 14...

"Their Stories, Our Heritage, Not Forgotten" Irish Heritage Week, 2...

How a 22-Year-Old Firebrand Became 'Meagher of the Sword'

Father Peter Paul Cooney: Faithful Servant

Honoring Father William 'Fair Catch' Corby

AOH Historian: Irish vs. Black Narrative in Draft Riots a Fiction

'Undaunted Courage': The Irish at Fredericksburg

The Easter Rising, America's Civil War, and 'The Minstrel Boy'

U.S. Warship Comes to Queenstown, November 1863

A Confederate Chieftain 'Crosses Over The River'

 'The Florence Nightingale of The Army of Northern Virginia'

'Come On Back, Boys! Give 'Em Hell, God Damn 'Em! We'll Make Coffee...

Colonel Patrick Guiney: Boston's 'Good Knight'

Character Assassination in 'Gods and Generals': Shaara Book Portray...

Two of America's Irish Heroes

In Pursuit of Lincoln's Assassin: Roscommon-Born James Rowan O'Beir...

Private Willie Mitchel: An Irish Confederate Boy

William 'Whack' Ryan: Martyr to Cuban Freedom

Long-dead James J. Shields faces GOP in new tussle

The Irish at Gettysburg

The Irish Brigades'S Fifth Regiment (116th PA)

The 35th Indiana: Hoosier State's '1st Irish': Part 1 & 2: Be J...

Dynamite Johnny O'Brien: 'A Captain Unafraid'

For Erin and America - James McKay Rorty

"Their Stories, Our Heritage, Not Forgotten" Irish Heritage Week, 2...

"Their Stories, Our Heritage, Not Forgotten" Irish Heritage Week, 2...

The 5th New York's Daniel J. Meagher

The Wolfe Tone Guard in Civil War California

Irish Confederate at Gettysburg

Fr. John Bannon -- 1st Missouri Brigade, C.S.A. (Irish Heritage Wee...

Band of Brothers: The Day the Irish Brigade Saved the 9th Massachus...

Semmes and the San Patricios: 'Dishonored and Dishonorable'?

Irish Rebels and the Baltimore Riots

Patrick Cleburne's Ireland

"Faithful to us here, we loved him to the last.": Col. Patrick Kelly

The Irish Fight for Grant at Cold Harbor

The First Republican President in Ireland, Parts 1-2-3: Ulysses S. ...

The Mystery of the 69th Pennsylvania's Irish Flags

In Pursuit of Lincoln's Assassin: Roscommon-Born James Rowan O'Beirne (Parts 1 & 2)

"Their Stories, Our Heritage, Not Forgotten" Irish Heritage Week, 2...

Restored Painting Captures Return of the 69th By Liam Murphy / WG H...

Band of Brothers: The Day the Irish Brigade Saved the 9th Massachus...

June 3, 1864: Irish Regiments Fight for Grant at Cold Harbor

How St. Patrick's Day Was Celebrated by The Irish Brigade in the Ye...

Among the Irishmen at Gettysburg

Confederate General's Family Saga: Anglo-Irish and Well-Respected

Confederate Major General Patrick Ronayne Cleburne

Special Report: The Irish Brigade Monument Unveiling

General Phillip Sheridan: Short in Stature, Tall in the Saddle

Views: 3777

Tags: American Civil War

Comment by Gerry Regan on April 25, 2014 at 4:44am

Mike, sorry, so what have you concluded -- the 69th's regimental bore a harp, as described in The Irish American, or sunburst, wolf and round tower? and if McDermott got that wrong, how credible is the rest of his book? What is the title of McDermott's work, BTW?

Comment by Michael H.J. Kane on April 25, 2014 at 6:01am

I think McDermott just described the second flag. Remember he and Colonel Davis were both hopped up  Fenians in 1864. There were few Fenians in 1861 and the women in Philadelphia would think the Maid of Erin was more important. By the way Davis got McDermott his promotion to sergeant major and adjutant,


Admin
Comment by Joe Gannon on April 25, 2014 at 11:53am

Gerry, McDermott was a member of the regiment and wrote a brief history of it, apparently for the rededication of their Gettysburg monument in September 1889. You can read the full text of it here: https://archive.org/stream/briefhistoryof00mcde#page/n87/mode/2up

Comment by Michael H.J. Kane on April 25, 2014 at 4:13pm

Gerry, thanks for adding the photos. Technically I'm back in the smoke signal era.

Comment by Gerry Regan on April 26, 2014 at 6:54am

Speaking of Bill Rose, fellows, can one of you invite Bill to join The Wild Geese, and The Blue, Gray and Green Group?

Comment

You need to be a member of The Wild Geese to add comments!

Join The Wild Geese

The Wild Geese Shop

Get your Wild Geese merch here ... shirts, hats, sweatshirts, mugs, and more at The Wild Geese Shop.

Irish Heritage Partnership

ZenBusiness:
Start a Business Today!

Adobe Express:
What will you create today?


Adverts

Extend your reach with The Wild Geese Irish Heritage Partnership.

Congrats to Our Winners

© 2026   Created by Gerry Regan.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service