Semmes and the San Patricios: 'Dishonored and Dishonorable'?

In November of 1846, as the war between Mexico and the United States raged, an unusual unit of the Mexican army was formed by General Santa Anna, it was called the San Patricios or St. Patrick's Company. Commanded by John Riley, a deserter from Company K of the 5th U.S. Infantry, who probably gave it the name, it was made up entirely of foreign-born troops. Although more were Irish born than any other nationality, about 40 percent were from England, Germany, Canada, France and native-born Americans, as well; but there was one thing the vast majority of them had in common: They were deserters from the American army. Less than two years later, 50 of them would be hung for desertion.

The desertion rate of the American army during the Mexican War was the highest of all American wars, double the rate of Vietnam. Why did the Patricios desert in the face of the enemy? Certainly it was not cowardice, since they would end up fighting in the same battles from the other side. For most of them, born in foreign lands, many having been here only a short time, their allegiance to the United States was not strong. Many had been brutalized by the harsh military justice system and many had faced racial and religious discrimination both in the army and out. The Mexicans were offering them land and the chance to live in a country where their religion was not looked down upon. Many also looked on the Mexican war as a war to expand the Southern slave holding areas of the country, it was unpopular with many segments of the population.

(Below: Hanging of thirty of the San Patricios
after the Battle of Chapultepec, by Sam Chamberlain.)

What was the attitude of American soldiers toward these deserters? Certainly very negative, as one might expect, but it varied from soldier to soldier. Lieutenant James Longstreet was a character witness at the trial of Sgt. Abraham Fitzpatrick, who was not a Patricio, but claimed only to have got drunk and captured by the Mexicans. He claimed to have twice refused to join them while in prison, but he was sentenced to be shot. It would be hard to conclude that his race was not the major factor of his conviction, since no evidence was given that he had been a Patricio. His sentence was commuted, however, and he returned to the U.S. Army as a private. He died of wounds he suffered at the battle of Molino del Ray the day after he rejoined the army.

Another American was not so forgiving in his attitude toward the Patricios. Raphael Semmes, then serving as a Navy lieutenant with the Marines in Mexico, had this to say about the 50 death sentences: "These sentences, which would have been appropriate at any time, were particularly so now. . . . The salvation of the army might depend upon an example being made of these dishonorable and dishonored men." So it would seem that Semmes' attitude toward those who would desert their countries flag was a rigid one. After all, these men, in spite of the loose ties many of them had to this country, had taken an oath of allegiance to the United States, had they not? Such men are "dishonored and dishonorable," he believed.

(Above: Captain Semmes on the deck of the CSS Alabama at Cape Town, South Africa - August 1863.)

Apparently, Semmes attitude had evolved a great deal less than 14 years later, when he resigned his commission, deserted his flag, and later fired on it as captain of the famous Confederate commerce raider CSS Alabama.

He sailed the Atlantic sinking and capturing ships, until the USS Kearsarge sank the Alabama off Cherbourg, France, on June 19, 1864, flying the flag he had taken an oath to protect. It was a flag he had been born and raised under, while most of the Patricios had only lived beneath it for a short time. Did he ever think about those 50 Patricios, who met their end on  a gallows? One would like to think so.

Semmes would face his own trial, for treason and piracy, in December 1865. He was also charged with mistreating prisoners and violating the rules of war. He never came to trial, however, as all charges were dropped after he had been in jail for three months.

(“Battle of the USS Kearsarge and the CSS Alabama 1864” by Jean-Baptiste Henri Durand-Brager: 1814-1879)

As he sat in that jail cell, contemplating the decisions he had made, loyalty, oaths and what a man fights for may not have seemed as black and white as it did to that Navy lieutenant back in Mexico. Perhaps if he had been tried, he might have ended up with a Mexican War veteran or two on the panel, men who may have recalled his attitude toward those soldiers who deserted their countries flag less than 20 years earlier. Would Raphael Semmes have been judged by them to be, "dishonored and dishonorable"?


Winfield Scott: Defender of Irish Rights ... Once

Cuimhin Linn - Nos Acordamos - Vivan Los San Patricios!

“The Irish Soldiers of Mexico” by Michael Hogan

“The Death of John Riley Revisited” by Michael Hogan

'The Irish Soldiers of Mexico' Reviewed

Raphael Semmes - Wikipedia

Views: 581

Tags: American Civil War, CSS Alabama, Mexico, Military History, Raphael Semmes, San Patricios, USS Kearsarge, United States

Comment by Thomas Michael Quirk on June 3, 2018 at 4:04pm

They deserted because of the bigotry against Irish Catholics it the US Army at that time . Mexico promised them land for serving.

Comment by Thomas Michael Quirk on June 3, 2018 at 4:05pm

Good story Joe.


You need to be a member of The Wild Geese to add comments!

Join The Wild Geese

The Wild Geese Shop

Get your Wild Geese merch here ... shirts, hats, sweatshirts, mugs, and more at The Wild Geese Shop.

Irish Heritage Partnership

Adobe Express:
What will you create today?


Extend your reach with The Wild Geese Irish Heritage Partnership.

Congrats to Our Winners

© 2023   Created by Gerry Regan.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service